The Periphery of extremely violent violence

A street dance. Mountain View Ave. Kingston. Jamaica. Home to many gay and lesbian Jamaicans. Over 300 people and a constant spread of extremely homophobic sentiments blaring to a group of largely marginalised members of one of the most violent communities in east kingston. It appears by our undue focus on that was Buju and ‘Boom bye bye’, a floodgate of homophobic lyrics, artists and dancehall culture swell the underground. Evidence of the fact that we constantly focus on personalities, heads and tips of icebergs ignoring nuclear issues.

What if an agitated and covertly aggressive dancehall culture has been lurking in the shadows, building/brainwashing young men, women and whole communities into systematic hate for same-sex relationships, waiting on the ripe time or opportunity to move from covert and lyrical to overt and physical? What if they are truly not just lyrics and style of dancehall, but an aggression so thick, it can no longer be penetrated, and is awaiting its fierce release? What if our undue focus on the lyrics of a song from the 1980’s and missed opportunities to encourage a general up-trend in respect for people, life as well as other good moral expressions in Jamaican music were missed?

It may not be that persons who find homophobic lyrics or harbour contempt for the homosexual lifestyle outnumber others who really don’t care. However it could be that the people who are most likely to be influenced or incensed by homophobia are more powerful in brute force and disregard for life, wrong/right and the law. Surveys have shown that over 75% of Jamaicans at some points, have no regard for private homosexual activity, whilst other studies have confirmed Jamaica to be a very homophobic nation. A most recent survey completed by Boxhill in 2012 followed up on the ‘National Survey of Attitudes and Perceptions of Jamaicans Toward Same Sex Relationship’ conducted in 2011, found that the situation had marginally gotten worse, and proved that: Jamaicans are aware of homosexuality, there is no closet, with over 50% of respondents being aware from as young as 14; agreed that homosexuality was prevalent in Jamaica and transcended social classes, highlighting the fact that poverty in urban areas was one of the main reasons for young men getting involved; the amount of people who believed that a homosexual can be changed to heterosexual rose to 53%; and over 88% and 83% of respondents believed respectively that both male and female homosexuality were immoral. Demonstrating that the false security enjoyed by lesbians, that male homosexuality is more harshly opposed than female homosexuality is not only misleading but dangerous; business persons were less likely to hire a homosexual due mainly to the concern that it would affect other staff – confirming that homosexuals may experience challenges in seeking employment; it also proved that the church and persons who listened to and was part of the dancehall culture (arguable a very large proportion of our young people) were most likely to be homophobic, whilst professionals and professional women seemed less inclined to be as riled up.

My experience with the dancehall lastnight was both heart-wrenching and eye opening. With threats of a retaliation for the acid attack on an alleged heterosexual thug in Bargain Mall, lastnight by a homosexual, the anti-gay and lesbian sentiments were palpable. As the selector spat his hate over blaring speakers, supported by the catchy and angry sounding lyrics of dancehall music, resounding gun salutes from both female and male members of the audience, I sank deeper into the ground. With the church and other groups flexing their muscles, testing and garnering their influences, no doubt propelled by some of the facts found in Boxhill’s study…I wonder banefully, have we lost the opportunity to sensitize and support Jamaica Land We Love to be one that our forefathers intended, teaching ‘true respect for all’, are our leaders’ who have been admonished to ‘stir response to duty call’ sleeping the sleep of death from potential political suicide? What does this mean for the gay community, after years of sporadic homophobic violence, but largely an appreciation in pockets of tolerance over the years, are recent activities such as the local church’s anti-homosexual agenda and the importance of homosexual issues and votes in the current Presidential campaigns in the US, a recipe for local LGBT disaster…are we even slightly prepared?

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “The Periphery of extremely violent violence

  1. pertinent and poignant questions. Do you suppose that we need a different narrative in advocacy efforts? do you suppose we need the other side of the homophobic narrative so that homophobia is not normalised? As you have insinuated; the brewing of homophobia underground has been normalised and has inoculated many. People are wont to feel the need for acceptance. What if we can present a plurality of stories; in which context the homophobic narrative will feel uncomfortable? There is a danger is promulgating a singular narrative and we as advocates and activists have allowed it to persist for far too long. We have not been prepared but it is never too late for a shower of rain.

    • I am not sure what to do immediately…I think the first thing would be to restore some amount of peace and calm to the community, identify adn establish the networks that reach as much gay ppl as possible as some kind of information centre and for reassurance…and only then after creating some form of unity can we start working on a way out…I have been anticipating these moments for a while, my biggest concern has been the lesbian community, as while gay men are unfortunately used to homophobia and have developed fairly successfully survival mechanism, lesbians are clueless and still under the unfortunate assumption that they are significantly less hated…this false sense of security is very dangerous.

      Just heard that a lesbian was raped lastnight as well. We need to act and now. I have been in dialogue with an agent of JFLAG around doing some sensitizations for lesbians…lets see how this goes.

  2. I have no sympathy for anyone who walks around with acid to acid ppl! That’s barbaric, worse seh it guh splash pon innocent ppl! Ugh. When things like that happen it only leaves room for homo hate to fester, anywho I don’t kno d story, Juss kno d acid thing is Juss too much. As long as the gay community keeps presenting itself ‘the enemy’ ignorant, violent, acid wielding it will never get better! In all the countries where lgbt lifestyles are accepted most gay ppl are seen by the masses as normal decent law abiding citizens no diff from ny1 else. Until we erase the stereotypes from the minds of the masses that will never happen, the music will follow suit, I mean the other day I started hearing alot of ‘keep it to urself’ vs ‘guh dead’ but with dat bargain mall incident I’m not surprised by what u experienced. Cah if dat acid did splash pon me I wulda share d same sentiments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: